Old meets new in riot shadow: pro-minority seen as anti-national

              Today it’s India vs Pak within country, not just on borders, says BJP MLA.. At a refugee camp in Muzaffarnagar. Express archive

In Muzaffarnagar, BJP-ABVP have taken out no marches on the JNU issue so far, nor burnt any effigies, as they have in Varanasi or Faizabad. But look closer in this small town where BJP posters proclaiming “Mission 2017” are already making an appearance and it’s there to see: quietly, but surely, the JNU issue is providing grist to those who last stoked memories of the communal conflagration here in 2013 in the bypoll campaign in February.

For all the BJP’s talk of “vikas”, development, its winning candidate in Muzaffarnagar, Kapil Dev Aggarwal, fought the election on the slogan: “Bahu beti ke samman mein, Kapil Dev maidan mein”. And: “Doodh or bread kahan batega, iska nirnay aap karein”.

The burden of that second slogan was not lost on its intended audience, the Hindus of Muzaffarnagar: it played upon insinuations that then SP MLA and minister of state for minority welfare, the late Chitranjan Swaroop, had favoured Muslim mohallas in the distribution of relief and provisions when communal violence scorched this part of western UP in 2013, forcing large numbers of the minority community to take shelter in relief camps for many months in the harsh winter.

On JNU, Aggarwal now says: “The country’s politics is moving towards a juncture where parties can go to any extent to win votes, they can even support those who talk of playing with the country’s self-respect and integrity. It is anti-national to raise slogans like those at JNU but it is worse to support those who do so. Today, it is India versus Pakistan within the country, not just on the borders”.

Strict action must be taken, he says, against those who have expressed support to the students of JNU — “it is wrong that Rahul Gandhi went there”. No leniency must be shown, he says, or this will spread, as it did, “in Punjab, Assam”. “There should be a high-level probe to find out who planned this, and from where came the internal support”.

He will soon get a “recording” that will reveal who “motivated” the JNU students, Agarwal smiles, declines to give details. Instead, he offers a theory: “Those who don’t like the BJP government, don’t like Modi ji, that he is winning accolades abroad, those who want to undermine him. They misled the students at JNU.”

In Aggarwal’s telling, the “they” in the JNU story is now the students, then their supporters, and then the Modi government’s political opponents. But eventually, “they” are the Muslims: “The community should come forward, to identify and isolate those who are terrorists”, he says. “Responsible Muslims should stand against terror. Only 5 to 10 per cent do so. This should be large-scale, tab hi vishwas hoga, (only then there will be trust). Had the Muslims in Godhra, and in the country, stood up against the crime (burning of kar sevaks in the train), the reaction (Gujarat riots of 2002) would not have happened”, he says.

Aggarwal does not say it, but his senior colleague in the BJP, Sohan Veer Singh, former two-term MP from Muzaffarnagar, spells it out: the JNU video, that had gone viral before the voting for the bypolls, helped Aggarwal win. Incidentally, this is contested by leaders of non-BJP parties in Muzaffarnagar who point to the abstention of the BSP, and the transfer of its vote to the BJP, as the decisive factor.

“It (JNU) certainly affected the bypolls”, says Sohan Veer Singh. “In 2014, the Modi wave separated the desh bhakts (patriots) from the others. People know about the Congress and the Communists, that they started making pacts with the Muslim League not long after Partition. That memory was revived in JNU.”

For Sohan Veer Singh, the JNU episode is as much about “day-and-night appeasement” as “anti-nationalism”. “What else is support for slogans that call for the dismemberment of the country to the chorus of Insha Allah, Insha Allah?” he asks. “Look at Pakistan, how they treat Hindus. Look at Bangladesh, how they turn out Hindus. And Kashmiri Pandits. They don’t feel their pain…. Kanhaiya was speaking their (the appeasers’) language”, he says. “Pakistan tortured Sarabjit, but here Kasab was well fed. The world is laughing at us.”

Across the city, Nitin Malik, businessman and UP West secretary of the BJP’s youth wing, the Bharatiya Janata Yuva Morcha, draws a more direct connection: between the Muzaffarnagar riots of 2013 and events in JNU. “Rahul Gandhi came to Muzaffarnagar and said that the ISI is in touch with people in the relief camps. Now he is saying he supports the students of JNU. He is the link”, he says.

Malik also says that “sanvaidhanik lacheelapan” or constitutional flexibility, must not be allowed to come to the aid of the JNU students and their supporters, including the teachers who have stood by them. “A special law must be enacted specifically to punish those who have extended support to the anti-national elements in JNU”, he says.

Malik has riot-related cases still pending against him, in which not a single hearing has taken place more than two years later, and he also went to jail. So did Sanjay Agarwal, district general secretary, Muzaffarnagar BJP.

He has been responsible for the “ghar wapsi” of “94 plus” Muslim girls so far, boasts Agarwal, in his drawing room, in his house in South Civil Lines. The problem in JNU did not happen suddenly, he says, “it is about 30-40 years old”. He offers a farming metaphor: “If a mango tree gets diseased, it will not do to just cut off an affected branch”. For him, the “core issue” that must be addressed is this: “Anti-national forces lie within. The Leftist stream of thought that has been dominant in JNU does not prioritise the good of the nation. Just look at how they have destroyed Bengal. Then there is the Islamist way of thought, which is similar to Leftism — both talk of socialism, neither has place for nationalism.”

The JNU episode represents a new turn in the national debate, says Agarwal. “The links of terror are right here. Who arranges for the hotel, the weapons, the passport? Look at the number of people from Pakistan caught in cases of terror”, he says. “Who were they sheltered by? It was our Muslim brothers who did it.”



  • Related News
  • Congress nominates AK Antony for Rajya Sabha election from Kerala.

    Congress state president, V M Sudheeran, on Saturday said the party has decided to field Antony as the candidate for RS elections.. A K Antony

    Former Defence Minister A K Antony will be the Congress candidate f...

    India 2016-03-05 11:30:49

    Situation did go out of control govt takes collective responsibility for any lapse: Captain Abhimanyu.

    During the agitation, properties, establishments and a house owned by Abhimanyu’s family were also torched by protesters in Rohtak. . Haryana Finance Minister Captain Abhimanyu at The Indian Express office in...

    India 2016-03-05 10:10:50

    Govt failed to anticipate scale of stir, says Haryana minister on Jat quota agitation.

    He added that the government has taken “collective responsibility” for the absence of an immediate administrative response to prevent the situation from getting out of control.. Haryana Finance Minister...

    India 2016-03-05 04:21:11

    Environment agencies cavalier, force courts to intervene: CJI.

    CJI Thakur said the Supreme Court would have had little role to play had the government agencies been doing their job properly.. Chief Justice T S Thakur

    WITH PRIME Minister Narendra Modi and Environment Minist...

    India 2016-03-05 04:17:44

    Assam board exam answer-sheets gutted in fire.

    Jorhat Deputy Commissioner Vasant Vishal Solanki said preliminary inquiries did not show any apparent sign of accidental fire occurring due to an electricity short circuit. .

    The Assam government Friday ordered...

    India 2016-03-05 04:13:41

    Sukma: 3 CRPF men killed in encounter with Maoists.

    Officials said while two commandos, identified as constables Linju N and Fateh Singh had succumbed to their bullet injuries on Thursday, their collegaue Lakshman Singh died on Friday..

    Three CRPF personnel have...

    India 2016-03-05 04:10:33

    Gujarat Quota stir: Man takes own life to make govt wiser.

    Upleta town also observed a bandh while its major villages like Bhayavadar and Moti Paneli remained shut as well..

    Upleta and Dhoraji towns of Rajkot remained shut on Friday to mourn death of a youth who had al...

    India 2016-03-05 04:00:30

    Asaram case: SC declines to order CBI probe into missing witnesses.

    A bench of justices Anil R Dave and Adarsh Goel said it could be raised before the Allahabad High Court as complaints on it have been lodged in Uttar Pradesh. . Asaram Bapu

    The Supreme Court Friday declined to ...

    India 2016-03-05 03:57:26

    Several complaints later, HRD Ministry moves to sack Pondicherry varsity V-C.

    Sources said the HRD Ministry has decided to process Krishnamurthy’s case as it has given her enough opportunity to present her side of the case.. Union HRD Minister Smriti Irani.

    Emboldened by the Presid...

    India 2016-03-05 03:53:23


    When I leave office, I will speak of it more freely: Arvind Subramanian. Gives examples from history

    How a country deals with its social divisions plays a major role in the trajectory of its economic developmen...

    India 2016-03-05 03:41:56

    Inquiry clears her but Leftist Allahabad University student head faces exit.

    While the report concludes that Singh’s seat should have gone to a reserved candidate, it makes clear that the “mistake” was committed by university staff involved in the selection process.. The i...

    India 2016-03-05 02:50:19

    The more Rohiths you kill, more will emerge from every house: Kanhaiya Kumar.

    Kanhaiya Kumar: "I am not a politician, I am a student. I have no intention of joining mainstream politics or contesting any election." . JNUSU President Kanhaiya Kumar with the union Vice President Shehla Rashid a...

    India 2016-03-05 02:30:35

    Indian nun among 16 killed by gunmen in Yemen; victims handcuffed, shot in the head.

    External Affairs Minister Sushma Swaraj urges Indians in ‘such danger zones’ to return home . Security forces at the retirement home in Aden, Friday. (AP Photo)

    An Indian nun was among 16 peopl...

    India 2016-03-05 02:24:43

    Sexual harassment case: Delhi HC dismisses plea to cancel R K Pachauris bail.

    The court said that "very cogent and overwhelming circumstances" were necessary for an order of cancellation of bail which has already been granted.. The court said while granting relief to R K Pachauri, the trial ...

    India 2016-03-05 02:08:04

    MP: House panel to help students deal with exam stress.

    Stressing on the need of moral education, yoga and meditation, CM Shivraj Singh Chouhan said sports period will be made compulsory in schools..

    Madhya Pradesh Assembly Friday unanimously decided to form a House...

    India 2016-03-05 01:54:46

    Bihar: Oppn attacks Nitish govt as Tej Pratap skips House session again.

    When JD(U)’s Phulwari Sharif MLA Shyam Rajak asked a question as to why the sex ratio in Bihar was increasing, rural development minister Shravan Kumar stood up to answer. .

    The Opposition BJP Friday targ...

    India 2016-03-05 01:52:48

    After PA Sangmas death, 7-day mourning in Meghalaya.

    In Shillong, where the Meghalaya assembly’s budget session had just begun, Speaker Abu Taher Mondal broke the news after Governor’s address and adjourned the House for the day..

    The demise of Meghal...

    India 2016-03-05 01:46:04

    Sumitra Mahajan recalls PA Sangma: He would try wit, humour and silence, whichever way it worked.

    After he ceased being the Speaker, Sangmaji never used his erstwhile position to seek time in the House for speaking.. PM Narendra Modi, Sumitra Mahajan pays last respects to former Lok Sabha Speaker P A Sangma at ...

    India 2016-03-05 01:40:41

    PA Sangma: Remembered, an important voice of the Northeast.

    Congress president Sonia Gandhi, Rahul Gandhi and other party leaders today condoled the death of former Lok Sabha Speaker P A Sangma.. Former Lok Sabha speaker P. A. Sangma

    Terming his contribution in the deve...

    India 2016-03-05 01:23:38

    Delhi confidential: Looking Beyond.

    But Deputy Chairman P J Kurien surprised some of the members on Friday when he ascribed a motive to disruption of the House.. PJ Kuriean

    Disruptions in Parliament, especially during the pre-lunch session, are n...

    India 2016-03-05 01:18:04